I often tell women I’m mentoring that doing A+ work is simply not enough.
If someone is excellent in their role but keeps their head down and doesn’t stretch themselves, their hard work can go unrecognized. Successful careers, promotions, and the type of recognition I hear women say they’re striving for comes from putting yourself in the position to take on an extra challenge. Beyond that, it takes finding the opportunity to let people know about your achievements and contributions. I see two common scenarios: either women worry about being perceived as arrogant, pushy or difficult if they ask for more, or they feel lucky to have the position or salary they currently have. Alternatively, I see men truly believing they add value and deserve more. Sadly, we are also still combating attitudes of some executives who don’t believe women “need” to make more money if they have a spouse with a successful career.
With end of year performance reviews around the corner, I’m sharing advice that can help women know how to prepare themselves to either negotiate a raise or a promotion confidently. Below are a few tips.
- Having your talents and abilities noticed requires intentionality. If you want to be elevated in a company or an organization, you need to have accomplished something above and beyond your job description. Schedule a meeting with your boss and let them know you are looking for opportunities to help you stretch yourself. Even better if you come prepared with an idea for what that opportunity could be, and how it will help the organization. Say yes to opportunities or projects that you feel “unqualified” to take on – they are what will give you the credibility to ask for more.
- Do your homework on what you should be getting paid. There are plenty of places to research typical salaries. In the corporate world there is actually a lot of transparency – many companies are required to disclose the salaries of their top executives. For the nonprofit world, you can use The GuideStar Nonprofit Compensation Report, a nonprofit compensation analysis based entirely on IRS data. Be sure that what you’re asking for isn’t unreasonable for the industry, region, and role.
- One of the most important things you can do is frame your argument by emphasizing what it will do for your organization or department. The key is to be confident without entitlement. What will you bring to the role that will add value? What changes can you make and how will they benefit your company? What will you be taking on in exchange for a higher salary? Of course you need to focus on what you have already done, but it’s important to remember that you’re not entitled to more responsibility or more money – it needs to continually be earned.
- For almost every speech, meeting or important conversation I have, I practice out loud first. Ask your partner, your friend or your colleague to role play with you, and run through the conversation. Have them tell you areas where you need to clarify. Make sure you’re comfortable enough with what you’re saying that you’re not speeding through it or talking too quietly.
- Make a habit of taking credit for your work. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve seen a woman give a presentation and there is a slide that lists 50 people who helped contribute to the success of the project she led. Additionally, I hear women say “we” instead of “I” when they very much should be saying “I.” Learn to feel comfortable owning your achievements, and find appropriate ways to let others know about what you’ve done.
What do you find most difficult in preparing to ask for a raise or a promotion? Do you have tips to share? I’d love to hear from you as well. It can be easy to simply accept what you are given, but then privately harbor resentment over not earning what you think you deserve. However, I always say, you can’t get what you don’t ask for.
This article is very interesting and offers immediate application for me because I always speak in ‘we’ terms. I love the endorsement for women to take credit for their work by saying ‘I’ when appropriate.
Thank you so much for this blog! I with I could contribute some advice here, but I am still learning (HA- will always be!)
In the last several months I have spent a lot of time thinking about woman’s equal pay, and how much accountability we have for the inequality. Obviously, its multifactorial, and we are not entirely to blame, but I realized that for myself and many other woman, that we are certainly less likely to ask (or demand) more pay compared to our male colleagues. A few years ago I had recognized that my position (a director level position, was actually slotted as a non-management position). I was missing out on key information by being miscategorized in my organizations system- so that made my ask much easier. I did get a small raise with my behind the scene “promotion”, and my initial feeling– GUILT! (Crazy!! Would a man feel guilty for getting a raise??)
With regard to celebrating success, having a personality that is improvement focused as been very good for my career, however, has been VERY bad for my ability to fully celebrate my successes. I can always find some thing that could have been done differently/ better. Despite being an optimistic, resilient person, I often find myself adding “BUT” too often (look at my second sentence, LOL). Self-recognition is key! I have been shifting away from the self- sabotage follow-up statements of “But I should have done x,y,z.” Somethings are better kept to oneself- identifying room for improvement is great for personal growth, however, there is certainly no need to point out your “flaws” consistently to others. In addition, excessive negative self-talk can wreak havoc on our confidence! Let’s be kinder to ourselves ladies!!
I think this is a great post, but I wonder what happens if you keep asking for stretch projects within your organization and no one responds. I’ve been trying so hard for so long and have asked so many people to help on specific projects or to be given a stretch project, but it seems to fall on deaf ears. I am not sure what I am doing incorrectly, if I am just overvaluing my skill set, or what? I want a challenge but just can’t seem to get a break. What advice would you give woman in this case?